Home

Banksia Hill crisis: Another former inspector of custodial services joins chorus of calls to overhaul system

Daryna ZadvirnaThe West Australian
Premium
Professor Richard Harding on his retirement from his role as inspector of custodial services.
Camera IconProfessor Richard Harding on his retirement from his role as inspector of custodial services. Credit: Lee Griffith/WA News

Another former WA prison inspector has slammed the State for its “cruel, inhuman and degrading” treatment of Banksia Hill detainees, accusing Premier Mark McGowan of victim-blaming and repressing the issue.

Richard Harding, who was the inspector of custodial services between 2000 and 2008, has described the youth detention centre as “a disgrace” and has called for the whole juvenile justice and detention system to be recast.

“The regime breaches international and domestic legislative standards,” he said in a letter to The West Australian.

Mr Harding said the decision to close Rangeview in 2012 — the remand centre for juveniles — and consolidate the population was the first major mistake by the Government.

“The increase in population and the need for staff to manage a more volatile mix of detainees changed the culture of Banksia, (and created) enormous stress on space and services,” he said.

WA's biggest courts and crime stories to your inbox

Sign-up to our weekly newsletter for free

Sign up

“The Department and the Government had been warned of the risk, to no avail. From that point on, things deteriorated rapidly.

“Since that time, the then-Liberal government and more particularly the McGowan Government has chosen the path of repression. Today the Premier has resorted to the classic posture of politicians who pursue a failed policy — blame the victims.”

Mr Harding said Banksia Hill had not always been in disarray and in his 2005 report had been described as a facility “characterised by an atmosphere of genuine positive regard”, where “young people felt safe”.

“The detained population at that time was similar to today’s: predominantly Indigenous, poorly educated, socially disadvantaged, having mental health problems,” he said.

“For all that, there was a positive culture, an optimistic vibe to the regime.

Former custodial services inspector Richard Harding conductiing an inspection of Kalgoorlie Regional Prison in 2005.
Camera IconFormer custodial services inspector Richard Harding conductiing an inspection of Kalgoorlie Regional Prison in 2005. Credit: Mirek Zabiello/Kalgoorlie Miner

“The place hummed with activity — education services, sport, counselling, and exercise and social interaction on the oval.

So how, in the space of 17 years, has it come to the present catastrophic state?”

Mr Harding’s sentiments echoed that of another former WA inspector of custodial services, Neil Morgan, and former WA Children’s Court president Denis Reynolds, who penned a searing analysis in The West Australian on Monday.

The pair — who have intimate knowledge of the system — accused the State Government of lying when left with no option but to transfer children from Banksia Hill youth detention centre to the adult Casuarina prison following a riot earlier this year.

“In truth, they did have choices and had failed to deliver on them: run Banksia Hill properly and have other child-specific places in the event of an emergency,” they write.

Mr Harding said Banksia Hill in its current state and regime was “irredeemable” and called for a proposal made more than 15 years ago to be reviewed.

“In 2006 there was a proposal to establish four small (15-20 person) juvenile facilities in regional areas: the Mid-West, the Goldfields, the Pilbara and the Kimberley,” he said.

“The rationale was to enable children to be linked to their communities during their detention, in the expectation that rehabilitation programs would be better supported. Somehow the proposal just faded away.

“The full review that must now be held might re-consider a version of that proposal. But above all there must be a re-conceptualisation of the cruel, inhuman and degrading manner in which the WA Government deals with juvenile justice, rehabilitation and detention issues.”

Upgrades to the Banksia Hill facility, including “child-friendly” Intensive Supervision Unit recreation areas, “anti-climb” roof and fences and refurbishment of observation cells, are set to be completed by mid 2023.

“The Department is undertaking priority works upgrading cells and infrastructure at Banksia Hill Detention Centre so all young people in its care can be safely accommodated and managed,” a DoJ spokesperson told The West Australian.

“The $25.1 million in major works, which include a purpose-built Crisis Care Unit are scheduled to be progressively completed by 2025/26.”

Get the latest news from thewest.com.au in your inbox.

Sign up for our emails